Sunday, March 02, 2008

The Wire Mondays: Episode 59, "Late Editions"

By Andrew Johnston



“Deserve got nuthin to do with it” -- Snoop

Is the best episode ever of the best TV drama ever QED the best single TV episode of all time? That’s not a philosophical conundrum I face where “Late Editions” is concerned, since my pick for the best series of all time is The Sopranos. Those who believe The Wire to be the finest series in the history of the medium, however, are going to spend a lot of time debating the question, since after two viewings it’s pretty clear that “Late Editions” is The Wire’s single best episode. I’m in a position to say this since I’ve been fortunate enough to see the series finale--which isn’t to say that The Wire’s final episode is a disappointment, just that it’s not as good as “Late Editions." Obviously, a lot of “Editions” serves to set up the finale, but the two episodes are not so tightly connected that “Editions” can’t be discussed separately, and without fear of spoiling the series finale.

As a big fan of George Pelecanos, I was thrilled to see his name attached to the teleplay credit for “Editions”; of the acclaimed crime novelist trio that has contributed scripts to The Wire (the others being Richard Price and Dennis Lehane), Pelecanos has always been my favorite, and his particular gift for dialogue is in evidence throughout the episode. We begin with Lester Freamon contemplating the clock code that Sydnor cracked last week, a code that quickly leads the younger cop to a spot in the boondocks where Marlo’s crew is about to take delivery on an enormous shipment of pure heroin. In the first of many great scenes that Lester scores--in a lot of ways, this is really his episode--he goes to Daniels and says he’s been investigating Marlo using resources from the Clay Davis case. I’m sure I’m not the only person who thought Lester was going to come 100% clean and reveal the truth about the serial killer, perhaps taking all the “credit” for the scam in order to spare McNulty. Instead, he leaves Daniels with the impression that he’s done nothing seriously inappropriate, and Daniels quickly signs off on the arrest of Marlo and his gang (Snoop, however, is able to avoid arrest because she’s at Levy’s office at the time of the sweep). Of all the great throwaway moments in the episode, one of my favorites is one of the most simple: The “uh-oh” tone of voice with which Pearlman asks “why?” when Daniels asks her if she’s sitting down before (off-camera) telling her that Marlo’s about to fall.

Marlo’s arrest is one of the few developments that doesn’t turn out to be too good to be true: No sooner does Dukie turn up than we see him being pressed into stealing scrap by the junkman who hired him last week (a literal junkman, as we learn at the very end). Daniels’ new job proves to be equally problematic when his balls are put in a vise by Carcetti’s chief of staff Michael Steintorf, who demands that he and Rawls cook the crime stats to produce a 10% drop in violent crime—or else. The situation makes Daniels the first of several characters who are faced with a choice between staying true to themselves or repeating the decisions that formed the fate of another. Daniels therefore stands at the brink of becoming the next Burrell, much as Michael, per Snoop’s final speech, is poised to inherit Omar’s mantle. Lester, generally a relatively sober fellow (though by no means a teetotaler), celebrates Marlo’s arrest by stepping into Bunk’s traditional role as McNulty’s drinking buddy.

Lester has always been the cop most inclined to see the big picture where the drug trade is concerned, so I was a little surprised by the suggestion that he had never before considered the role that Baltimore’s sketchier defense attorneys play in financing the business. The scene where Davis spells it all out for him, however, is classic. His blackmailing of Davis turns out to be the ultimate extension of his plan to use anti-Davis resources to take down Marlo, and it leads to the intriguing revelation that the courthouse leak is a level above Prop Joe: Levy bought the leaked documents before turning around and selling them to Joe. Still, the coolest part of the scene comes when Pelecanos goes into the realm of “fan service” by having Davis reminisce about how he scammed Stringer Bell.

I was dearly hoping for a return appearance by Bunny Colvin and Namond Brice before the end of the season, and their visit didn’t disappoint. Namond’s participation in a debate tournament, describing how little the U.S. is doing to combat the spread of HIV in Africa, shows that Bunny is as effective a foster father as one would expect him to be--and given the precariousness of Dukie’s position at the end of the episode, it’s damn nice to see that at least one of the kids from Season Four is unquestionably on the right path. Carcetti’s apology to Bunny for how he handled Hamsterdam didn’t seem quite in character for the mayor (or at least didn’t seem fully motivated), but so be it.

What I loved the most about the episode--and which motivated me above all to proclaim it the best Wire ever--are the episode’s two big speeches: Marlo’s monologue in jail and Bubbles’ speech from the podium at the NA meeting. Marlo has seldom so much has raised his voice in the past, so it was fascinating not just to watch him lose his cool but to see what could make him do so. Omar, it seems, had more insight into Marlo’s psyche than was apparent at the time--if Snoop hadn’t kept her boss from learning that Omar was calling him out, Marlo would have most likely fallen to him. Marlo’s seething anger at his name being taken in vain allows Jamie Hector--already a very intense actor--to display a fury we hadn’t seen before, and it’s mesmerizing. Bubbles’ speech was arresting for different reasons--essentially, it’s the climax of a character arc that began in his very first appearance, and it’s hard to imagine a better final outcome for him. It was genius of Pelecanos and Simon to keep Bubbles’ moment of doubt offscreen--even before he started to tell the story, it was clear he didn’t fall off the wagon that day, but that made me no less inclined to pump my fist in the air when he said that he didn’t get high when he couldn’t contact anyone else in the group.

The least progress toward a final resolution came on the Sun front, where Gus expanded his investigation of Templeton’s manufactured quotes and stories but little else happened. As a result, I’m going to keep most of my thoughts on the newspaper story line on ice until the finale airs, since so much of this episode's Sun action is pure set-up. And little enough happened with McNulty that I’m going to refrain from diving into his activities as well.

I’ll wrap things up by asking a question that left me stumped after both my viewings of the episode, and which also left our illustrious host and publisher scratching his head: Why does Herc tell Levy that the cops are running a wire on Marlo? Under the circumstances--with no evident leak in Marlo’s gang to serve as the source of the clock code, nor with there being any good reason for the police to even have Marlo’s number--doesn’t that come awfully close to self-incrimination?
______________________________________

Andrew Johnston is the television critic for Time Out New York.

187 Comments:

Blogger Matt Zoller Seitz said...

I felt pretty sure that the exchange between Carcetti and Bunny Colvin was a very coded, subtext-ridden exchange -- the mayor asking Bunny not to bring up Hamsterdam because it would damage the mayor's chances to gain the governorship, and indicating that the reward for his silence will be a job at the state level. That's what I made of Carcetti's rather pointed look back at the camera crews mid-conversation.

Dunno about Herc, though. That whole business was weird. Is Herc an idiot?

Second lingering question: Right before the SWAT raid on the re-supply meeting, why did that one white cop lying in the weeds take his shirt off? I couldn't see any motivation for it except to prove he'd been to the gym. Is there some tactical thing I'm missing?

Over and above everything else, this episode established Lester Freamon as just about the baddest motherfucker every to wear a Baltimore PD badge. He owned the hour. I loved seeing his bow-legged loping stride as he walked around the lineup of Marlo and his arrested co-conspirators. The ep was full of moments that strong. It almost made me wish we could see a Lester spin-off.

2/25/2008 1:59 AM  
Blogger Matt Zoller Seitz said...

also: Nice "obituary" for Omar here. Hattip: Heaven and Here.

2/25/2008 2:08 AM  
Blogger Matt Zoller Seitz said...

Final thought: Agreed that this might be the best single episode of the series, though the Ep in Season Three where Stringer Bell dies is up there as well.

2/25/2008 2:18 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

The Wire continues its tradition of truly excellent penultimate episodes (if memory serves, Stringer Bell's death and that scene where Randy yelled at Carver in the hospital both ended the penultimate episodes of their respective seasons).

I think the cop taking off his shirt was just his attempt to get rid of tics and bugs that were biting him in the field.

2/25/2008 2:18 AM  
Anonymous Carmichael Harold said...

I found the episode to be heartbreaking, never more so than when Dukie started down the path that Bubbles has just, finally (hopefully) stepped off.

Though The Wire has always been about making obvious parallels using context and intercutting, I especially liked them showing Michael and Kima simultaneously taking down one of their mentors. I worry about what happens to Michael in the finale (though I'm hoping the inferences that he is becoming Omar means that he'll survive).

Matt, I second your wish for a Lester spin-off. After the scene tonight, I wouldn't mind at all if Clay Davis co-starred.

2/25/2008 2:39 AM  
Blogger wstroby said...

A fitting send-off for Snoop, I thought, facing her fate with no apologies and no fear. And she got a great final line as well.

2/25/2008 3:29 AM  
Anonymous hng said...

Why did Herc say what he said to Levy? Because he didn't get enough acknowledgement from Carver, so he had to toot his own horn (in a roundabout way) to Levy. Herc is desperate for some kind of recognition and respect, is happy to see Marlo get taken down, and can't resist rubbing Levy's nose in how the Bawlmore PD outsmarted Marlo and Levy. As I think everyone knows, Herc isn't very bright.

Dozerman took his shirt off because the bugs were biting. How taking your shirt off keeps the bugs from biting is another question that remains unanswered.

And yeah, it really shouldn't take a blackmailed Clay Davis to inform Lester that it's slick lawyers who teach drug lords how to launder money. I thought every fifth-grader knew that much.

2/25/2008 6:02 AM  
Anonymous Crip said...

"Why does Herc tell Levy that the cops are running a wire on Marlo?"

Here's my theory...remember a few episodes ago when Levy realized Marlo was using cell phones again? He made the offhanded comment to Herc that business was about to pick up?? I think Levy was hoping that comment would prompt Herc to run to Carver with Marlo's number. Levy knows he won't get a big payday if Marlo's crew steers clear of the law. Otherwise, what purpose is Herc really serving on Levy's payroll?

2/25/2008 9:56 AM  
Blogger Matt Zoller Seitz said...

Crip: That scenario you suggest is positively Hitchcockian in its complexity, and with so many things that could have gone wrong. I think it's just one of those details that never quite got ironed out.

2/25/2008 10:01 AM  
Anonymous hng said...

Interesting theory, crip. But would a lawyer really want an employee who goes behind his back and snitches to the cops about their clients? Herc's purpose on Levy's payroll is to hangout with his old cop buddies and get info about what the cops are up to.

I have a bad feeling that the case against Marlo will be thrown out of court because of the illegal wiretap.

2/25/2008 10:01 AM  
Blogger sphalen said...

Going with what HNG said about Herc's role of hanging out with his cop buddies and finding out inside information as part of his job as defense investigator, I believe Levy sent him over there to find out information regarding the "C.I." and how the bust came about because of what Marlo told him about there not being much possibility of a snitch. Earlier in the episode he mentions that Marlo runs a tighter ship than the police department, so he probably does have doubts that it's a legitimate CI after what Marlo told him. If you just think about it logically like a lawyer would, a snitch being used to tell them how his organization uses the phones just seems a lot less likely than them having a wiretap in the first place and figuring out the phones that way.

Herc also talks about how they used resources from the serial killer case which reinforces the theory that he went over there specifically to get information and bring it back to Levy.

2/25/2008 11:44 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Carcetti apologizes to Bunny about the SCHOOLS EXPERIMENT (which Namond was a part of and its clear Bunny considers pointing him out to the mayor as an example of what kind oof future could've been had by some of the other kids too)

Carcetti had nothing to do with Hamsterdam. He did stop funding/refuse to fund further Bunny's program in the schools. That scene had absolutely nothing whatsoever to do with Hamsterdam...

2/25/2008 11:47 AM  
Blogger sphalen said...

Also, regarding the Crip comment that Levy wanted Herc to steal the number, I don't really think that would be the best way for Levy to maximize the amount of money Marlo could bring for his firm. As Clay Davis pointed out to Lester, Marlo is consistently going to be paying Levy in one way or another regardless of whether there is a trial or not. The long con is far more profitable than the short con.

2/25/2008 11:51 AM  
Blogger Alice said...

Anon-
Carcetti specifically referenced Hamsterdam when apologizing to Bunny.
Carcetti was the one who came to Bunny when he "discovered" Hamsterdam and asked to see what it was about, and then did nothing to help when it all came out.
Carcetti knew nothing about Bunny's involvement in the school project, he was busy meeting with the governor when Bunny came in for the meeting.

2/25/2008 12:39 PM  
Anonymous james said...

I agree that is one of the best episodes of the entire series, and it's the first time in quite a while I felt a real payoff from so many plot lines. This was a very satisfying episode, and that's not a feeling I often have after watching the Wire. There are always strings attached or something to tether whatever progress is made. By the end of the episode, things seemed to be going so well that I started to feel like I was being played. What's the catch? Will the entire case against Marlo be thrown out because of the McNulty's illegal wiretap? Will Herc's stupidity ruin so much hard work in yet another season? Is Simon just setting us up to be disappointed? I honestly don't know, but nothing would surprise me in the finale.

A few other thoughts I had when watching.

- I also found the scene with Carcetti and Colvin very out of place. My original thoughts were that he was apologizing for Hamsterdam, but a couple of comments above seem to indicate it was the school program. If that's the case, how did Carcetti even know about it? He never attended the meeting about ongoing funding and Michael certainly didn't pass it along.

- I wonder how much of Kima's decision to reveal McNulty's plot had to do with the scene of her and Elijah a couple of episodes ago. Her meeting with Carver drew an interesting parallel between the two. Carver was unquestionably effected by what happened to Randy, and it's a large part of who he is this season. I wonder if Kima's thoughts as she recited the Baltimore version of Goodnight Moon lead to her realization that "the little things matter."

- Loved the mythologizing of Omar's death that was already taking place on the streets. The comments by one of Michael's crew (Spider?) about how the killer were three Pimlico Boys with semi-autos was classic.

- During the amazing farewell scene with Dukie and Michael, I kept wishing Dukie would think to seek out Prez and ask his help. I honestly don't see Dukie becoming an addict given his intellect and general disdain at how his family was because of it. He is capable of being more, and most of this season has been an ongoing quest to escape what he was born into. I leave hope that there may still be redemption in store for him.

- Loved Lester's brief mention that he's still involved with the ex-stripper from season 1. I had been wondering about that for a while.

- Still wondering if the courthouse leak is a character we've seen on screen. Who are the real suspects if it is? Pearlman? Bond? Phalan? None of those seem very likely.

Very much looking forward to the last episode. Despite the criticism, I think this season has been excellent.

2/25/2008 12:49 PM  
Anonymous ninety_nine said...

Regarding Herc -- remember how angry he and Carver were in seasons one and two. Carver matured. Herc, as it has been proven repeated, is and stayed dense and immature.

Ratting back to Levy might simply be his 'fuck you' to his old "bosses" (Freamon and McNulty), and to everyone who he feels slighted by for not standing tall when he got caught bending the rules. In a strict moral sense, very little of Herc's actions were malice by intent. His worst deed -- the Randy situation -- was due to incompetence, and so he's a long way from feeling culpability. He's probably thinking, 'all I did was lose a camera and I got fired'. Why should Freamon and McNulty get a pass for far worse?

2/25/2008 12:55 PM  
Anonymous HNG said...

"Herc also talks about how they used resources from the serial killer case which reinforces the theory that he went over there specifically to get information and bring it back to Levy."

I'm sure that's why Levy sent Herc over there, but I'm not sure that Herc was okay with those orders.

If you're right, then that would be yet another out-of-the-blue character reversal in a season full of them. Herc hates Marlo and wants him to go down. And I think he'd still feel some loyalty to and affection for his cop buddies, enough so that he'd balk at wrecking their case against Marlo. It also doesn't jibe with his earlier behavior, when he gave Marlo's cell-phone number to Carver...unless of course you accept crip's theory about that being Levy's plan all along.

But if it turns out the way you're suggesting, I'm gonna be even more pissed off about what Simon has done to the show this season. I'd prefer to think that Herc is just too stupid to censor himself in front of Levy than to think he's deliberately colluding with Levy in wrecking the case against Marlo.

2/25/2008 1:16 PM  
Anonymous hng said...

Also, I'm not sure this really constitutes evidence, but Herc saying too much to Levy is paralleled in this episode with blabbermouth Monk, who lets slip to Marlo that Omar was calling him out. Maybe it's part of a "loose lips" theme.

2/25/2008 1:34 PM  
Blogger Sean said...

My take on Herc is that he has always wanted credit and respect for his deeds. During the exchange this epsidode with him and Carver, Herc could not get a confirmation that his good work, giving Carver Marlo's cell phone number lead to a wiretap and massive arrests. Once again, the BPD couldn't or wouldn't come through for him. Since Carver or no one else could give him credit, he went back to Levy and looked for validation from him, by helping Levy build a defense. Herc is between two worlds now, in my opinion, and ultimately, he wants a pat on the head, as always.

Oh, and I agree, this episode is fantastic. It seems to be a pattern with The Wire. The second to last episode is basically the climax of the season-long plot. The last episode is the resolution. Which is why these second to last episodes are the most satisfying. The Wire's like a novel, but its season long episodic-arc follows Aristotle's theory of the "well made play" exactly. Sorry if that was too artsy, but I like the way Simon does that, mirroring the Greeks in many different ways.

2/25/2008 2:06 PM  
Blogger Matt Zoller Seitz said...

HNG: "I'd prefer to think that Herc is just too stupid to censor himself in front of Levy than to think he's deliberately colluding with Levy in wrecking the case against Marlo."

Me, too.

2/25/2008 2:13 PM  
Blogger Stephen Denney said...

What was the significance of the final scene where Daniels and the prosecutor (forgot her name) find the cell phone in the evidence room? Was this McNulty's phone? I hope he doesn't go to jail, and that the case against Marlo's gang doesn't collapse. Too bad the next show will be the finale.

2/25/2008 3:51 PM  
Anonymous Tom said...

"What was the significance of the final scene where Daniels and the prosecutor (forgot her name) find the cell phone in the evidence room? Was this McNulty's phone?"

Stephen,

The prosecutor's paperwork contains a phone number that was supposedly the serial killer called on. When she dials that number, on her phone, Marlo's phone -- seized earlier by the police -- is the one that rings.

2/25/2008 4:03 PM  
Blogger Matt Zoller Seitz said...

Heaven and Here on #59.

"The decision to off Michael—or, as it turned out, his semi-affectionate offing of Snoop, which kind of felt like someone murdering his big sister/guidance counselor. The issue was that Mike didn’t follow orders, thought too independent, and just generally wasn’t cut out for soldiering. Telling that both Marlo and Chris didn’t, or really didn’t want to, believe that this marked him as the snitch. But you’ve got to assume that one of them ultimately gave the order, so I won’t dwell too much on what they think his true nature is...However, when Snoop lectures him in the car, you could take it two ways. Either it’s proof that Michael should’ve stayed in school, kept the anger inside, and tried to be a normal kid. “You were never one of us,” Snoop spits matter-of-factly. The question is, what was he never? Snoop, the consummate mindless soldier? Chris, who knows how and when to voice his opinion? Or a gangster in general? There’s still the possibility that, in making this move, Michael showed what we’ve suspected all along: That’s he destined to end up like Marlo, because he’s just too smart, shrewd and determined to work for anyone else. Hence that flipping of what Chris and Snoop taught him about how to scope out a potential hit. He took the field manual and used it for himself."

2/25/2008 4:36 PM  
Anonymous Andrew said...

Regarding Herc, here's how I see it. Herc knows nothing about the wiretap being illegal, so he doesn't think he's giving anything away by telling Levy that it's a wiretap. He doesn't believe that he's potentially freeing Marlo by simply telling Levy that the cops are using a wiretap. He clumsily tries to cover himself by saying that he has no idea how they got the number.

2/25/2008 7:07 PM  
Blogger Dan Jardine said...

The scene of Michael scoping out the meet ahead of time is clearly intended as evidence that he has learned well and Chris and Snoop's knee--always arrive early.

It is also an interesting parallel to the maneuvers of Omar, who likewise spent a lot of time in the backseats of cars surveying the territory and gathering evidence.

I think it is entirely possible that Michael is intended to be the successor to the throne. But it is Omar's throne, not Marlow's.

2/25/2008 7:30 PM  
Blogger Dan Jardine said...

Oh, and as for Herc, he's an absolute moron. He simply has no clue that telling Levy will result in the case against Marlow being tossed out of court.

Herc is easily my least favourite character on the show--even less likeable than Marlow, and that's saying something.

btw, big props for Jamie Hector in this episode. His explosive response to the news of Omar calling him out shows us just why Marlow became the king of the castle. Positively riveting and thoroughly intimidating when riled up, he is.

2/25/2008 7:33 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

its strange to me that no one has mentioned the car scene where michael drops off bug at his aunts house. those kids were phenomenal in that scene- well they are phenomenal in all their scenes.

it broke my heart when michael sent bug off.

it was also heartbreaking when dukie tells the story about throwing the pee balloons at the terrace boys from season 4 and michael cant remember it. it was his loss of innocence....he completely forgot what it was like to be a kid.

2/25/2008 8:49 PM  
Anonymous dcdame said...

Matt asked: Right before the SWAT raid on the re-supply meeting, why did that one white cop lying in the weeds take his shirt off? I couldn't see any motivation for it except to prove he'd been to the gym. Is there some tactical thing I'm missing?

I figured it was to ratchet up our anxiety that the bad guys might spot the surveillance team because Dozerman (I think that's who it was) kept going above the grass horizon -- & if they were spotted, the bad guys might successfully flee or otherwise be better prepared to defend against the SWAT team. I know they weren't that close (hence the binoculars), but I still got antsy (no pun intended) that their cover would be blown.

2/25/2008 9:06 PM  
Anonymous HC said...

An optimistic read of the Herc-Levy comment is that Levy has the courthouse leak. Levy knows that there was no aboveboard Stanfield wiretap. If we're lucky, Levy lets that slip and goes down for the courthouse leak.

2/25/2008 10:43 PM  
Anonymous dave said...

I am guessing there is no hope that the Greeks will go down in all of this.

2/25/2008 10:50 PM  
Blogger Randy said...

Long-time reader, first-time commenter. Only a couple of things to add:
- omigod, it's CASS FUCKING WINTHROP!!! (Or was I the only one who used to watch Another World with his mom back in the mid-80s?)
- a phrase I keep thinking of when I think of this great, unmatched, wondrous achievement is "A quantum of solace." I hate that phrase a Bond movie title, but I love the poetry of it, and I think it applies to The Wire. The show may be a devastating critique of the myriad problems that plague big cities, but we get the balance, the occasional 'happy endings' - Namond, Bubbs - that make the whole thing bearable. (In Leonard Cohen terms... "There is a crack in everything / that's how the light gets in.")

I can't believe there's only one episode left.

2/25/2008 11:52 PM  
Blogger Matt Zoller Seitz said...

dcdame: That's the most convincing explanation I've heard, though it still doesn't explain why the cop did it in the first place (taking off your shirt to guard against biting bugs?). It's a really tiny thing to fixate on, and I don't want to blow it out of proportion, though, so I'm going to accept that explanation and move on.

Randy: I'm stunned that nobody has quoted Leonard Cohen in these threads before now (or am I forgetting somebody)? Welcome.

2/26/2008 12:13 AM  
Blogger Matt Zoller Seitz said...

Dan Jardine: "btw, big props for Jamie Hector in this episode. His explosive response to the news of Omar calling him out shows us just why Marlow became the king of the castle. Positively riveting and thoroughly intimidating when riled up, he is."

Yeah -- I also thought this scene drove home the fact that (as Andrew alludes in his recap) Chris and Snoop were, all things considered, good lieutenants. I've heard it said that the number one responsibility of any job is to make sure that the person one rung above you on the ladder doesn't have to deal with any shit that's going to divert them from their responsibilities. Serving as a filter, in other words. Chris and Snoop obviously decided early on that if Marlo got word that Omar was calling him a punk, it would push two of his panic buttons, homophobia and machismo, and basically make him worthless as a leader. They were right.

2/26/2008 12:16 AM  
Blogger Matt Zoller Seitz said...

Also: Marlo's "My name is my name" is a brilliant line, worthy of the most poetic flights of language on "Deadwood."

2/26/2008 12:17 AM  
Anonymous Blackirish said...

I thought it was poignant that Snoop, the ultmate butch sociopath, when facing death finally reaches for her the one thing she always denied ...her femininity. Like any other girl she worries about how she appears. Her last words....

Snoop..."How's my hair look Mike?

Michael..."You look good girl"

Out.

2/26/2008 1:20 AM  
Blogger Randy said...

“Deserve got nuthin to do with it” -- Snoop

This, of course, is also pretty much the same line that Clint Eastwood says to Gene Hackman right before killing him in "Unforgiven". When I saw that line at the opening, and that it was Snoop who said it, I thought there's no way they'd be THAT obvious to use the same line in the same context. And as the ep developed, and it became clear that Snopp was going to (try to) kill Mike... well, I'm just really glad that the show turned my expectations on their head: Snoop said it to Mike shortly before HE killed HER. Very nice turn-around.

2/26/2008 1:32 AM  
Anonymous Andrew said...

Also: Marlo's "My name is my name" is a brilliant line, worthy of the most poetic flights of language on "Deadwood."

It's also a rather brilliant callback a line spoken by Vondas in the season 2 finale. When asked what Nick Sobotka knows, he responds, "He knows my name, but my name is not my name." It's a good way of illustrating the fundamental difference between these two breeds of criminal.

2/26/2008 2:22 AM  
Anonymous Ben Livant said...

HNG Said: "And yeah, it really shouldn't take a blackmailed Clay Davis to inform Lester that it's slick lawyers who teach drug lords how to launder money. I thought every fifth-grader knew that much."

So what is the point of the scene? With respect to plot resolution, it would seem that the final episode will deliver another big bust, or at least set the wheels in motion for one, higher up the food chain. There has been a fair amount of attention here to Herc, treating Levy as secondary or merely instrumental to this focus. But Jesus, if ever there was a scumbag we'd all enjoy seeing impaled, it's Levy. (And hey, we go back with him to Season One, unlike scumbag Scott who just showed up this season.)

Turning from plot to theme, in my estimation the scene between Lester and Clay Davis resonates with meaning that might just be past the comprehension of every fifth-grader. Perhaps it is dramatically contrived to have Clay lecture Lester on the concentric rings of the drug business as they emanate out from the criminal dealers to the legal establishment. But Simon & Co. still want to lecture us at least one more time before the curtain falls. Hence, Clay recalling the real estate hustle he and others pulled on Stringer Bell back in Season Three is not just wrap-it-up writing to give every character a nod before the house lights come up. Stinger Bell remains THE essential figure in The Wire precisely because he was self-consciously attempting to make the main move from robbing people with a six-gun to robbing them with a fountain pen, thank you Woody Guthrie.

I was broken up by the breaking up of Michael, Dukie and Bug; and not because I was ever especially drawn to any of these three as individual characters. What I was always attracted to was the presentation of them collectively as a FAMILY. Contra the religious right-wing with it's supposedly Biblical interpretation of what constitutes a family, those three guys - boys, they're just boys - remind me of the kind of make-shift but genuine familial bonds John Steinbeck validates with such dignity in his literature. Carcetti at yet another photo-op, sound-bite session spins out the rhetoric about how drugs destroy communities and families. Michael, Dukie and Bug make it plain that some folks have to loose their family more than once.

And it would have been balance if Bubbles' - excuse me - Reginald's sister had seen fit to come to the meeting. But she didn't. That balance was not given. Yet we can hope. I have never been so stupid about make-up, I mean, theatrical cosmetics. Who knew Bubbles was so handsome? I don't hear much discussion here about his declaration in the church. But come on people. Didn't he look strong? Didn't he sound good? Don't you just believe he is going to make it?

Kima had to. She just had to. Just like Beadie had to stick it to McNulty on the domestic side, Kima had to stick it to him on the professional side. The Wire cannot be accused of provided a female perspective for the most part - what's the ratio of female to male characters overall? - never mind a feminist agenda. Still, it wasn't Bunk, right, it was Kima and I think that this is worth interpreting.

Lester Freamon rocks!

Then - Ben

2/26/2008 2:36 AM  
Anonymous straight outta silver spring said...

Ben,

were you aware that David Simon has said that Fran Boyd and Woody Guthrie are people that he considers to be heros?

Don't have a whole lot to add to this discussion so much as been said and I'm taking it all in, so much great stuff.

One thing I don't think has been mentioned. When Michael dropped Bug off at his aunt's he left Bug with a shoe box full of money and a promise that there will be more where that came from. This leads me to believe that Michael does not view himself as being out of the game, not yet or anytime soon.

Also, part of me thinks that too many people have too much at stake to ever let the truth get out about the fake serial killer. Carcetti's run for governor has been built in large part on the attention he is lavishing on the homeless because of the serial killer, and he looked awfully good telling (lying to) the press that they never gave up on those murders in the vacants. All of these things help his run. His Chief of Staff told Rawls and Daniels to "get creative", which is exactly what Jimmy did. Maybe Daniels will be inclined to go along with this? The problem is I cannot see Pearlman agreeing to prosecute a case that she clearly knows is built on an illegal foundation. In seasons past they are never able to bring the case in fully. Maybe this time when they don't play by the rules (and why should they the game is rigged) they end up getting the end result they want. I wouldn't mind Jimmy or Lester going down for what they did, as long as it doesn't let Marlo off the hook.

Between Andrew J. and Sepinwal, the write-ups and the commenters... Obviously, MZS, Ben, Dan, hng, andrew(from the comments, you are the man) and so many others, it's been incredible.

2/26/2008 3:54 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I think the Carcetti and Bunny scene was just Carcetti's conscience caughting with him (he has those from time to time). Carcetti has no real connection to Hamsterdam, so Matt explanation doesn't work, what Bunny could say about it to hurt Carcetti? That after learning about it he went to Bunny to get his side of the story first? Carcetti was very confortable spining the numbers to the press when he sees no other than Major Bunny Colvin, the man whose Hamsterdam project helped to launch Carcetti's mayorial bid, he felt genuinely bad at the time about going to press (D'Agostino had to point out to him that Hamsterdam was done anyway), so he abandons the press and goes talking to Bunny. It felt to me as maybe the one honest moment Carcetti got the whole season.

2/26/2008 5:23 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Does anyone else thinks Marlo's "Kill first, ask if someome is snitching later?" might be his downfall? He sends Snoop to kill Michael, but Michael kills her. The same Snoop that early Marlo made it clear to Levy was the only person not in jail that actually had the info that Lester claimed had coming from a CI. The cover up of the McNulty mess might just finger dead Snoop as the CI. Final blow to Marlo: after three seasons of killing whoever gave him the smallest suspicion of becoming a snitch he tells Levy that he is 100% sure that he can trust Snoop.

2/26/2008 5:33 AM  
Anonymous hng said...

DAN: "So what is the point of the scene? [...] Perhaps it is dramatically contrived to have Clay lecture Lester on the concentric rings of the drug business as they emanate out from the criminal dealers to the legal establishment. But Simon & Co. still want to lecture us at least one more time before the curtain falls."

I think you just answered your own question: It's one more chance to lecture the audience and one more chance to bring up Stringer Bell in passing. Lester certainly didn't learn anything he didn't know before (or should have known, anyway).

I'd like to see Levy fall, but I've got a gut feeling he won't.

ANDREW: " Herc knows nothing about the wiretap being illegal, so he doesn't think he's giving anything away by telling Levy that it's a wiretap."

I'm sure that's right, but it just underscores Herc's stupidity. He should have taken the hint from Carver and kept mum. But Herc's breathtaking cluelessness, his desperate need for recognition, and his irresistile urge to gloat will once again screw things up.

2/26/2008 6:06 AM  
Anonymous hng said...

ANON: "Does anyone else thinks Marlo's "Kill first, ask if someome is snitching later?" might be his downfall?"

Could be. It fits in with a longstanding Wire theme: Don't keep shitting on your workers or eventually there'll be a comeuppance.

2/26/2008 6:13 AM  
Anonymous hot breakfast said...

I agree that Lester probably didn't learn a whole heck of a lot that he didn't suspect already when talking to Davis. But, without the word from Clay he wouldn't have the deeper understanding he has now and he wouldn't have something that he might be able to leverage Levy with.

ALL DUE RESPECT to Andrew Johnston, I've loved your work here, you insights and the comments your writing has brought out. However, I must mention that it felt a little bit like a slap in the face to this dedicated Wire fan when you admit in the first paragraph of your write-up of what you believe is the greatest episode ever of The Wire, that you think The Sopranos was the better show. I know I'm being petty but that stung a little bit.

2/26/2008 10:06 AM  
Anonymous hng said...

HOT BREAKFAST: "But without the word from Clay he wouldn't have the deeper understanding he has now and he wouldn't have something that he might be able to leverage Levy with."

I'm not quite sure what Lester has to leverage against Levy. Some innuendo muttered by Davis isn't enough to get a warrant for Levy's files, is it?

I think the purpose of that scene was to afford Simon & Co. another opportunity to inveigh against sleazy lawyers and to mention Stringer Bell (since Stringer can't really make an appearance in the final-season round-up).

But I totally agree with you about the superiority of The Wire over The Sopranos.

2/26/2008 10:38 AM  
Anonymous Ben Livant said...

HNG: But I LIKE it that Simon & Co. lecture us again because I agree with the lecture. (By the way, don't blame "Dan" for my opinions. He isn't me. He only plays me on television.)

Meanwhile, forgot to mention how neat is was - and it would have had to have happened this way - that McNulty did not personally participate in the bust. It never dawned on me that - of course! - he could not be there for it. So, the scene with Lester drunk and happy and Jimmy sober and not rang very true, what with McNulty being denied the actual satisfaction. At the same time, Lester is not stuck with the bogus homeless serial killer and Jimmy most certainly is.

Then - Ben

2/26/2008 11:00 AM  
Anonymous Ben Livant said...

Straight Outta Silver Springs: No I was not. So good for me and thank you.

Then - Ben

2/26/2008 11:02 AM  
Anonymous hng said...

Sorry, "Ben". I always get you two confused. I wonder why.

2/26/2008 11:45 AM  
Blogger A. McCann said...

Andrew J. I'm so glad you pointed out George Pelecanos' role in this episode.

He has alway written the penultimate episode for each Wire season and I whole-heartedly encourage anyone to start reading his fiction.

You'll notice so much of his touch on the Wire from his books. The scene between Snoop and Michael and the set-up is all Pelecanos. The characters and the audience know the outcome, but it's still heart pounding intense as you go through the scene with them. Like Lester said, it's the journey.

I really liked the fact that Cheese (Method Man) was blasting a (fellow Wu Tang) Ghostface song when he entered the warehouse. Just another in a long line of visual/audio inside jokes the creators pile into each episode, including the triumvirate of crime writers AJ mentioned all having their books being read by a Wire character.

Good call to the poster who mentioned an escape clause for McNulty's mess could be pinning the CI label on Snoop, but part of me wonders, especially after seeing how she went out, if anyone would ever believe she was anything other than a pure solider of the game.

Finally, my two cents on why the Wire is superior to the Sopranos is because I near tears during Bubble's er- Reginald's speech and instinctively clapped along with the group when he finished. That payoff moment along with the deep emotional pains in my stomach and heart as Wallace, Sobotka, Stringer (all from Pelecanos' scripted episodes), Bodie, and Omar died are why this show is unequaled. No other show has gotten me as emotionally involved with it's characters' lives than the Wire. Plain and simple.

2/26/2008 11:55 AM  
Anonymous hng said...

"Finally, my two cents on why the Wire is superior to the Sopranos is because I near tears during Bubble's er- Reginald's speech and instinctively clapped along with the group when he finished."

Me, too. Bubbles breaks my heart. He's the one character I really want to see achieve some kind of redemption. If Simon doesn't give it to him, I'm gonna be FURIOUS!

2/26/2008 12:31 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Great comments everyone... although I believe Snoop's final line was: "How does my hair look, MANG (not Mike)?"

2/26/2008 12:49 PM  
Blogger kant69 said...

Wait, what?

How is it possible that Andrew has seen the season finale? It wasn't included on the dvd screener and it won't be shown on On Demand next week?

I thought HBO was keeping the finale close to its chest, but apparently not.

Sucks that most of us have to wait two weeks though to see the finale - with a bit of luck, it will somehow leak online anyway.

2/26/2008 12:59 PM  
Anonymous Crip said...

"why did that one white cop lying in the weeds take his shirt off?"

I noticed during my second viewing was that Dozerman was working the camera during that stakeout. But he puts the camera down after one photo to fool around with his shirt.
Seems like they have plenty to support their case, but if photographic evidence was needed, Dozerman may be on the hook...

2/26/2008 1:40 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

With regards to the jail scene, which, by the way I loved: I cannot shake off is this echo of a similar situation in season 3 when Avon gets out of jail. Slim, Avon & String are sitting in a car when Avon first realizes that Marlo took his corners and String kept that info away from him. Slim says what is going on, just as Monk did and String tries to downplay it, just as Chris did. What ensued shortly after that was Avon’s relentless fight to regain “his name” which, in turn, drove a fatal wedge between him and String. I mean, if Avon gave his boy up for the sake of his name and his reputation, I am petrified to think what Marlo is capable of doing for the same goal. Is the similarity intentional or coincidental?
I am not saying that Chris is Stringer; I just have this unclear thought that is bugging me. Maybe some of you intelligent and insightful people could help me out.

2/26/2008 1:44 PM  
Blogger Nomi Lubin said...

Ben: "Contra the religious right-wing with it's supposedly Biblical interpretation of what constitutes a family . . ."

OK. I know I'm likely to be alone here in defending, God forbid, religious conserviatives, but someone's got to do it:

Ben, man. You don't give it a break, do you? Only a moron would not know that Michael, Dukie and Bug are family.

Before I'm crushed by your mighty pen I'll squeeze in a few thoughts.

I agree with hng and others about Herc's motivation for blabbering to Levy. Crip, I think you might be overplaying this one.

About seeing Bunny and Namond, I'm of two minds. I wanted to see them too. And given my anger at the darkness last week, I feel a little funny saying this, but it felt pasted-in to me, a little forced.

BUT, I may simply not know the rhythms of the show well enough. I sometimes don't watch the episodes more than once, nor have I gone back to earlier seasons; I miss nuances and I think I miss the kinds of rhythms that weave in and out of episodes and seasons. So, I'd love it if someone explained to me how to see that scene as a more organic part of the whole.

To a lesser extent, I feel a bit this way with Bubbles triumph. That, of course, I wanted even more. I should just be overwhelmed with gratefulness that he made it . . . but did it not feel a little pat? Please, tell me I'm all wrong.

Michael as the new Omar (definitely Omar and not Marlo) and Dukie as the next Bubbles . . . ouch. That hurts. Was that a little contrived as well? Maybe, but . . . oh, those kids did reach me individually and I could cry thinking about them.

Marlo's monologue was incredible. And yes, the line "my name is my name" is indeed a truly poetic flight of language. (Matt) And the echo of Vondas' "He knows my name, but my name is not my name," is magic. Thank you, Andrew, I never would have remembered that.

2/26/2008 2:41 PM  
Anonymous Kathy said...

My comment on ShirtGate - though it seems counter-intuitive to take off your shirt in response to bug bites, I thought he took it off in order to see if there were any ticks attached to him.

I concede I may be too optimistic in viewing Dukie's situation but I don't think we're supposed to believe he's necessarily doomed to becoming a junkie. As mild-mannered as he comes across, Dukie has a strong sense of self-preservation. He would not have survived this long without that. We've seen so many old faces come back this season, I don't think it's out of the realm of possibility that Dukie reaches out to Prez in the finale. Barring that, he may latch on to the junk dealer to survive until he comes up with something better. I guess I just don't see Dukie giving up on himself, at least not yet.

I can't figure out what's going out with Herc either. I'm hoping it becomes clearer in the finale.

Part of me wants to see McNulty hung out to dry for his actions but I don't think that's going to happen. A scandal of this magnitude would destroy Rawls and Daniels and the department, not to mention Carcetti's political future and as angry as they are going to be, covering it up is the only option.

2/26/2008 3:21 PM  
Blogger Andrew Johnston said...

Hot Breakfast--

I'm sorry if stating my preference for The Sopranos stings, but rest assured that I consider the shows to be so close to each other in quality that the margin is razor-thin. It's sort of like how it is with the Velvet Underground and the Rolling Stones, my two favorite bands of all time...I give the VU the edge for reasons that involve personal preferences, but I also have a really deep, personal connection to the Stones' music and have probably spent just as many hours listening to them over the course of my life. More than anything else, though, I was trying for a snappy lede that would let me quickly delve into my argument.

2/26/2008 3:56 PM  
Blogger Simon Hsu said...

This post has been removed by the author.

2/26/2008 4:29 PM  
Blogger Simon Hsu said...

I haven't much to add; the high points - the drug bust, Marlo's "name" speech, Namond's success, Snoop's death, Bubble's incredible sharing, Bug/Dukie/Mike's split - have all been covered nicely.

I don't think I've ever let out a greater sigh of relief than when I saw Mike scoping out Riggs & Calhoun in advance. How possible was it that the writers would counter the high of Freamon's bust with Mike's death? In retrospect however, the dissolution of the Bug-Dukie-Mike family was far more devastating than the would-be shock of Michael simply getting popped. Seeing them split paths was one of the downers in an episode pleasantly filled with uplifting aspects.

Call me a simpleton, but removing your shirt simply makes it easier to scratch your itches and check for ticks, no? I guess you could call that a tactical move.

I thought it clever that the punchline for the evacuation joke ("you evacuate buildings, not people") in episode 1 (2?) was revealed in this one.

2/26/2008 4:36 PM  
Blogger Nomi Lubin said...

Kathy: "I don't think it's out of the realm of possibility that Dukie reaches out to Prez in the finale."

Ahhh, dare I dream? I don't know. The poetic fatalism of the two implied paths -- Michael's and Dukie's -- is pretty compelling. Well, I go into every episode of The Wire trying (and failing) not to hope. So, I guess the next one will be no exception.

I agree about ShirtGate(ha).

2/26/2008 5:07 PM  
Blogger Dan Jardine said...

Nomi, you really are a hopeless romantic, aren't you? I can relate: I'm in recovery myself. One day at a time.

But no wonder The Wire gets under your skin like a six-legged tic.

2/26/2008 8:00 PM  
Anonymous Ben Livant said...

Nomi: I am crushed that you anticipate being crushed by my - gulp! - mighty pen. My phallic insecurity is only surpassed by my ideological concern. Considering the Woody Gutherie reference I made earlier, I would rather you mock me for waving a six-gun around.

You say: "Only a moron would not know that Michael, Dukie and Bug are family." While I generally do not equate offensive ideas with innate stupidity, on this occasion I will defend myself by saying that the religious right-wing, supposedly Biblical interpretation of what constitutes a family is moronic. Hence, my point.

Meanwhile, I will plead guilty as charged to not giving it a break, although I suspect you and I have somewhat different notions about what "it" is. You are, of course, entitled to be displeased with my politicized thematic preoccupations. Yet, I feel you sell The Wire a tad short in this regard. This is to clarify that I did not doubt the obviousness of Michael, Dukie and Bug being a family. On the contrary, my intention was to give Simon & Co. credit for precisely this obviousness; uh-huh, contra the religious right-wing... you know... like what I said before... type thing... (SFX: Ben coughing, his powerful writing implement flaccid in his hand).

RE: Shirtgate: I agree with DcDame:

"I figured it was to ratchet up our anxiety that the bad guys might spot the surveillance team because Dozerman (I think that's who it was) kept going above the grass horizon..."

In short, stage business for suspense with no deeper meaning. Hello Nomi, check me out, giving it a break. Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar. (And a pen is just a pen).

Then - Ben

2/26/2008 8:07 PM  
Anonymous james said...

I'm surprised to see so many comments about Dozerman's shirt removal, but why should that stop me from adding one more? In terms of the plot, he removed his shirt to help scratch/inspect for other insects. Thematically, I think this was added partly as comic relief (I chuckled) and partly as a way of putting the bust into perspective. McNulty has risked his career and possible freedom for this moment, Lester has devoted hundreds of hours of his life, yet the only thing important to Dozerman before this supposedly triumphant moment is the bugs crawling on his back. It actually reminded of something Herc and Carver would have done back in seasons 1 and 2.

2/26/2008 8:55 PM  
Blogger 2090gh said...

I agree - a great episode - my only quibble - the scenes at the paper - why do we have cardboard villains at the paper (all the top honchos) when the heroes and villains in the rest of the wire are such a mix of good, evil, stupidity,intelligence, etc. How did they rise so high on the food chain if they are so appallingly stupid?

2/26/2008 10:00 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

ANDREW,

can you please tell us how you've managed to see the season finale already?

2/26/2008 10:24 PM  
Blogger Matt Zoller Seitz said...

Anon: HBO made the finale available to critics. I don't know how many critics, or which ones. Andrew and I have both seen it. To preserve surprises, we will neither discuss it nor show it around.

2/26/2008 10:33 PM  
Anonymous Jack said...

@ A. McCann:
Good call to the poster who mentioned an escape clause for McNulty's mess could be pinning the CI label on Snoop, but part of me wonders, especially after seeing how she went out, if anyone would ever believe she was anything other than a pure solider of the game.

The thing is, "how she went out" was a pretty obvious assassination. It would be very easy for the police to say "she was our informant, and it looks like someone found out about it, because she was gunned down in her car, like, the day after we arrested damn near everyone in the organization but her." Just my 2 cents.

2/26/2008 11:34 PM  
Blogger Andrew Johnston said...

By the way, the Slate guys are all wrong when they claim that Isaiah Whitlock Jr. introduced his "sheeeeeeit" in 25th Hour (my favorite Spike Lee movie ever, so I certainly don't mean to denigrate it): 25th Hour was a holiday-season release in 2002, but The Wire premiered in the summer of that year, and Clay Davis made numerous appearances during the first season (though I can't cite offhand which episode contained the first "Sheeeeeeit").

2/27/2008 12:16 AM  
Blogger Sean said...

Anon said: Carcetti had nothing to do with stopping Hamstardam in Season 3. I'm certain that's incorrect. Then councilman Carcetti forced Royce's hand to shut down Hamsterdam all but against his will. Carcetti's campaign manager told Carcetti to run with that information, that Hamsterdam was continuing, to go public with it, come out against it in the press, and burn the incumbent mayor. He sat on the info first, allowing Bunny to show him around. But ultimately, his political aspirations lead him to burn Bunny's project, and Bunny, simply because Mayor Royce was not acting to shut it down and attempting to work with it/live with it as a health/community strategy. Ironically, I don't think Carcetti ever knew Bunny was involved with the Corner kids program in season 4, effectively shutting Bunny Colvin down twice. "I guess there's nothing that can be done." Taken so many ways. One of which, could mean Colvin's hope for progress working within any system. ...getting crushed by post-industrial institutions

2/27/2008 12:26 AM  
Blogger Matt Zoller Seitz said...

Andrew J. : "I can't cite offhand which episode contained the first "Sheeeeeeit""

I'll bet that somebody reading this thread knows the answer.

2/27/2008 12:39 AM  
Blogger Nomi Lubin said...

Dan: "No wonder The Wire gets under your skin like a six-legged tic."

Yes! In fact, I just had to take my shirt off . . .

2/27/2008 12:45 AM  
Blogger dronkmunk said...

Its was in season 4, don't know the episode. I am pretty sure they lifted that from spike lee.

2/27/2008 12:59 AM  
Blogger dronkmunk said...

..Or possibly the 25th Hour novel, but something tells me that was Spike's touch.

2/27/2008 1:00 AM  
Anonymous Andrew said...

Clay Davis's part in season 1 was actually quite small. He only appeared in two or three episodes. His only major scene came in the second to last episode where he gets pissed off at Daniels over his driver (Day-Day) being pulled over. If I had to guess, that would probably be the scene where his first "sheeeit" came, but I'd have to check to be sure.

2/27/2008 1:06 AM  
Blogger Matt Zoller Seitz said...

If Andrew J., Barry Maupin or Alan Sepinwall are reading this, we need a definitive "sheeee-it" ruling. Anybody game?

2/27/2008 1:17 AM  
Blogger Dan Jardine said...

Nomi, you are shameless. Of course, I can't get enough. I guess recovery isn't going so well tonight.

2/27/2008 2:49 AM